PimpMyViews
All articles

Creator research · 6 min read

Your Views Are Lying to You: How to Tell If a YouTube Video Did Well

By PimpMyViews Team ·

PimpMyViews graphic: Did it do well? Five myths about YouTube numbers, with Neil and an example slow-burner video at 4X its channel's normal

You open YouTube Studio, and your new video has 2,000 views. Is that good? Is it bad? Most people have no idea, so they guess. And that guess is usually wrong.

If you run a faceless channel, your numbers are all you have. No one tells you how a video did. There's no face in the comments saying "great job". There are just numbers, and some of them are lying to you. This guide shows you how to tell if a YouTube video did well by busting five myths about YouTube numbers, then giving you one simple question to judge any video.

Every channel and number below is a made-up example, but the patterns are real.

Myth 1: more views means a better video

Here are two faceless channels. The first is a small history channel with 12,000 subscribers, and its new video has 24,000 views. The second is a big compilation channel with half a million subscribers, and its new video has 150,000 views. So the big channel won, right? Not even close.

The small channel normally gets about 8,000 views a video, so 24,000 is three times its normal. The big channel normally gets 400,000 views, so 150,000 is less than half its normal. The small video was a hit. The big video was a flop.

Outlier score = views ÷ the channel's normal (24K ÷ 8K = 3X)

Views on their own tell you almost nothing. What matters is views compared to your channel's normal. That's called an outlier score, and we cover it in detail in the outlier method.

Myth 2: if a video flops in two days, it's dead

This one hurts faceless channels more than anyone. A lot of faceless videos get found through search. Someone types "why did the Romans leave Britain", and your video is there. Those videos don't explode on day one. They grow slowly, every single day, for months.

Say a history channel posts two videos in the same week. After two days, video A has 3,000 views and video B has only 900. So video B is a flop, right? Look again after 90 days: video A has stopped at 6,000, and video B has 32,000 and it's still growing. Video A was a quick spark. Video B was a slow burner, and slow burners are gold.

  • Don't judge a video at two days old.
  • Check it at 7 days, and again at 28 days.
  • Always compare it to your other videos at the same age.

YouTube Studio even helps you here. On a video's overview, it ranks the video against your last 10 uploads at the same point in time. That ranking is far more useful than the raw view count.

Myth 3: a low click-through rate means a bad thumbnail

Click-through rate is how many people click out of everyone who saw your thumbnail, and a lot of people panic when it drops. But when a video starts doing well, YouTube shows it to more and more people: first your regular viewers, who know you and click a lot, then people who've never heard of you, who click less. So your click-through rate goes down while your views go up. That's not a problem. That's YouTube testing you with a bigger crowd.

YouTube says that about half of all channels have a click-through rate between 2% and 10%, so don't chase one magic number. Look at click-through rate and impressions together:

ImpressionsClick-through rateWhat it means
Going upFallingNormal: YouTube is testing a bigger crowd
FlatLowTime to look at the thumbnail and the title

And compare to your own videos, not to someone else's screenshot.

Myth 4: a higher retention percentage always wins

Average percentage viewed sounds like the perfect number, but it depends on how long the video is. Imagine a four-minute video where people watch 60%: that's about two and a half minutes each. Now imagine a 20-minute documentary where people watch 35%: that's seven minutes each. The lower percentage gave you almost three times the watch time.

So look at average view duration too, the minutes, not just the percentage. Then look at the shape of the retention graph:

  • The first 30 seconds matter most. On a faceless channel that's usually a voiceover and a few clips. If a big chunk of people leave here, your opening isn't keeping the promise from the title.
  • A flat line after that means you're doing something right.
  • A slow, steady slope is normal.
  • A sudden cliff tells you exactly where people got bored.

Myth 5: subscribers are the number that matters most

Subscribers feel like the score. But on most faceless channels, the majority of views come from people who aren't subscribed. They find you in search or in suggested videos, they watch, and they leave. In YouTube Studio you can split your views into subscribed and not subscribed. Try it: you might find that 80% or 90% of your views come from people who've never subscribed.

That's not bad news. It means YouTube is showing your videos to new people, and that's how channels grow. A video that brings in lots of new viewers but only a few subscribers can still be one of your best. Subscribers are a nice bonus. Views from new people are the engine.

How to tell if a YouTube video did well: the one question

When you want to know if a video did well, ask one question: how did it do compared to my normal, at the same age?

  1. Find your normal: take your last 10 videos, sort them by views and pick the one in the middle.
  2. Compare your new video to that at 7 days and at 28 days.
  3. Two times your normal is good. Three times or more and you've got an outlier: study that video and make more like it.

And here's one more thing that will make you feel better. Your normal is the video in the middle, so by definition about half of your videos will be below normal. That's not a failure. That's just how a middle works. A video at half your normal isn't a disaster, it's one data point. Only start to worry when video after video sits below your normal: then something has changed, and it's time to look at your ideas, your thumbnails and your titles.

So stop checking your views every hour. Check at 7 days, check at 28 days, and spend the rest of that time making your next video.

Your homework

Open YouTube Studio and find your channel's normal. Then pick one video you thought was a flop and check it again with these five rules. Was it really a flop, or was it a slow burner? For a quick way to see every video's views next to the channel's normal, with an outlier score, see how to find outlier videos.

Frequently asked questions

How many views is good for a YouTube video?

There's no single number. Compare the video to your channel's normal (the middle of your last 10 videos) at the same age. Two times your normal is good; three times or more is an outlier.

When should I judge how a YouTube video did?

Not at two days. Check at 7 days and again at 28 days, and compare it to your other videos at the same age. Search-driven videos often grow slowly for months.

Is a falling click-through rate bad?

Not if impressions are going up. As YouTube shows a video to people who don't know you, they click less, so CTR falls while views rise. A low CTR with flat impressions is the sign to rework the thumbnail and title.

Do subscribers matter most on YouTube?

On most faceless channels, most views come from people who aren't subscribed. Views from new people are what grow a channel; subscribers are a bonus.

Get The Outlier Report

Each week, the biggest breakout videos across popular niches — straight to your inbox. Free.

By subscribing you agree to receive emails from PimpMyViews. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy Policy.